Forests and the European Union Resource Network (FERN) reckon that if this is so, absorbing the UK’s annual greenhouse gas emissions would require planting an area of forest the size of Devon and Cornwall every single year – and maintaining them forever - but they think the concept of accurately predicting trees’ carbon performance is "fantasy" with no solid basis in science.
Not everyone is even convinced that tree-planting works. Critics point out that trees eventually die and rot, releasing carbon back to the atmosphere, and may have serious adverse environmental consequences by soaking up scarce water or decreasing biodiversity.